This is one of those case files where the paperwork changes the whole story. Carl “CJ” Spencer, also known as Jizzle, was killed on September 26, 2011 near 417 East 60th Street, but the report behind his murder did not stay simple. What started as a daylight shooting near 60th and King turned into a massive murder file filled with witness statements, shell casings, street rumors, photo identifications, an

d a ballistics connection that Reddit has debated for years.

The early version described two groups, gunfire, and chaos on the block, but the deeper paperwork points toward something more targeted. Investigators recovered multiple shell casings across the scene, including .

45 caliber evidence that later became one of the biggest parts of the case. Years after CJ was killed, new statements brought the names Raason “Lil B” Shaw and Carlton “TuTu” Archer into the official file, while Reddit users started connecting the evidence to a much bigger theory.

Inside the full case file, this breakdown goes into the day CJ was dropped off, the crime scene evidence, the witness who came forward years later, the alleged confession after the shooting, the Lil B and TuTu identifications, the 600 and Jaro City connection, the IBIS ballistics link, the same gun theory, and why detectives eventually closed the case without a trial.